Here’s my take on car titles: titling is a sloppy, messy business, and it causes problems for millions of people in this country. Part of the trouble is that buyers lump very different pieces of paper together. An accident on a history report, a salvage title, a title that’s late, a car still on its factory paperwork, and a title that’s been washed are five different things. Here’s how I sort them out.

An accident on record is not a salvage title

A structural damage disclosure or an accident on a history report is not the same thing as a branded or salvage title. They are very different.

Carfax describes structural damage as damage to the main structure of the car, like the frame or unibody, and says accidents from minor to severe can cause it (Carfax). That’s a history entry. It tells you something happened. It does not change the title.

A salvage title is a brand the state puts on the title itself. In Texas, a salvage vehicle is one where the cost to repair it was more than the car was worth before it was damaged, and insurance companies usually make that call. Before it can go back on the road, it has to be rebuilt and inspected (TxDMV).

The Georgia Attorney General’s consumer office puts it plainly. A title record and a vehicle history report are two separate records. A clean title only tells you the car has no brands, and a car can have a clean title and still show an accident on its history report (Georgia Consumer Protection Division).

So a reported accident or a structural disclosure is a reason to look closer and get a structural inspection. A salvage brand means the car was written off. Don’t treat them as the same thing in either direction.

Title delays are common now, and here’s why

Title delays are very common as more and more cars are sold across state lines. That wasn’t much of an issue 30 or 40 years ago, because cars were mostly sold regionally. The title usually changed hands within a small area.

Now cars sell at a national level and go from one state to another state. Each state has its own forms, its own rules, and its own office. A paper title has to physically get from one place to the next. As long as titles are physical, they get lost in the mail, they get bundled up with other paperwork, and they get lost. Getting a replacement title can be very difficult. A late title by itself does not mean something is wrong with the car. It usually means the paper is stuck somewhere.

An empty car carrier truck parked at a truck stop

Open MSOs: a new car that isn’t really free to pass along

Every new car starts life with a Manufacturer’s Statement of Origin, also called an MSO or MCO. TxDMV calls it the birth certificate for a motor vehicle. The manufacturer issues it to its franchise dealer, and it gets turned in at the first retail sale so a title can be issued (TxDMV Dealer Manual).

Some vehicles are sold with that MSO still open, meaning the car has never been titled. In Texas, a new motor vehicle has to be sold by a licensed franchise dealer (TxDMV). If a dealer who isn’t franchised for that brand ends up with it, that dealer has to title it in its own name first, and then it’s a used car. In practice, a car sitting on an open MSO can’t just be handed off to the next buyer unless the dealer actually registers it to themselves. For most people, it’s basically non-transferable.

If someone offers you a “never titled” car outside a franchise dealer of that brand, ask who will be titling it and how. Rules vary from state to state.

Title washing: how a wrecked car comes back clean

Title washing is when a salvage or flood-damaged car is moved to a different state to get a “clean” title and hide its damage history from the next buyer (NICB). The Justice Department’s NMVTIS site explains that it can happen when a car is retitled in a state that doesn’t check with the state that branded it (NMVTIS).

The pattern I’ve seen goes like this. A car is severely damaged, and a lot of the time it’s from California. In my experience, California damage reporting is very limited because of the state’s privacy laws. California law does keep accident reports confidential to the DMV and the Highway Patrol, released only to people involved and others with a proper interest (California Vehicle Code 20012). Someone buys the destroyed car in California, sends it to Alabama, gets a new title there, and then moves it somewhere else again. By the time it reaches a buyer, the paperwork in their hand can look clean.

The good news is that NMVTIS is designed to keep every brand a state reports on a car, so moving it to another state doesn’t erase that record (NMVTIS). Check the full title history, not just the title in front of you.

Titles need reform, and states are only starting

This is the bigger problem. States need to move to electronic titles. For right now, paper titles cause a lot of problems for people registering a car from one state to another state. You have a physical document that has to be signed, mailed, checked, and accepted by a different state’s office before you can register the car.

Some states have started. West Virginia has moved to a fully digital vehicle title, and says other states are required to accept it as legal proof of ownership (WV DMV). Arizona lets buyers and sellers transfer a title online (Arizona MVD). Virginia offers an online title transfer for its residents (Virginia DMV). Massachusetts just announced the first phase of its electronic title this month, but paper is still the default there, and it only covers eligible private sales between Massachusetts residents for now (Massachusetts RMV).

There’s also a national effort. AAMVA, the association of state motor vehicle agencies, launched an electronic title system that lets a vehicle record move between states without a paper title. Maryland, Massachusetts, West Virginia, and Arizona were the first states named (AAMVA). That’s real progress, but it’s a handful of states. Most of the country is still on paper, and that’s where the delays and the headaches come from.

What I do about all of it

I read each piece of paper for what it is. A history report tells me what’s been reported. The title tells me what the state says about the car. The title history tells me where it’s been. I want all three, and I want to know where the title physically is before I get attached to a car.

Motorphilia has been Your Automotive Matchmaker since 2002. From our home base in Tyler, TX, we help buyers all over the country and deliver nationwide, so cross-state paperwork is something we deal with all the time.

If you want help finding the right car, start with The Motorphilia Match Maker. You can also call or text us at (430) 247-2588.

Check us out at www.motorphilia.com, and keep us in mind for any car needs, especially Tesla!