Here’s my take on shopping for a used Tesla: don’t stop at the model year. Two cars from the same year can be very different machines, and they can be worth very different amounts.

A 2023 Model X we looked at recently is a good example. The first estimate assumed it had Tesla’s older Autopilot computer, Hardware 3. It turned out to have Hardware 4, and that alone could make it worth at least $5,000 more, about a 10% bump. That gap is typical in our own market experience: HW4 cars tend to sell for roughly 10% more than comparable HW3 cars.

How to check used Tesla HW3 vs HW4 on the car

If you can get to the touchscreen, that’s the surest way to tell. Go to Controls, then Software, then Additional Vehicle Information, and look for the Autopilot computer line. It will show version 3 or version 4 (Not a Tesla App). Tesla added this readout as of software update 2024.38, so older software may not list it. If you can’t sit in the car, ask for a photo of that screen. Hardware 4 cameras also have a reddish tint on the lenses, easiest to see up front and on the side repeaters (Not a Tesla App).

The changeover didn’t happen on one date for every Tesla. Hardware 4 started showing up on Model S and Model X cars in early 2023, with deliveries reported by March (Teslarati). On the Model Y, U.S. factories appeared to switch around late May 2023, while Shanghai moved in early 2024 and Berlin later that spring (InsideEVs, Drive Tesla). The refreshed Model 3, often called Highland, has Hardware 4; earlier Model 3 cars do not (Not a Tesla App). Those dates are approximate, and a 2023 Model S, X, or Y can have either computer. Tesla has not offered a path to upgrade Hardware 3 to Hardware 4 (Not a Tesla App).

Why pricing guides miss mid-year changes

Standard book values and pricing guides group cars by model year, so they miss build changes made partway through a year. A late-build car, for example an HW4 car from a year that also had HW3 builds, is likely to price closer to the next model year than to the year it’s grouped in. If you only look up “2023 Model X,” you can land on the wrong number, just like that first estimate we ran.

Other differences the model year won’t tell you

The Autopilot computer isn’t the only difference that changes what a car is worth.

Battery and range are a big one. A Model 3 Standard Range is not the same car as a Long Range. On the 2024 Model 3, the base car was rated at 272 miles of range, and the Long Range Rear-Wheel Drive at 363 miles, with a higher peak charging rate as well (Edmunds). Tesla also shifted its standard-range cars to lithium iron phosphate, or LFP, packs (Electrek).

Seating matters too. On a Model X, five seats are standard, and six- or seven-seat interiors are options. A five-seat car has no third row, and from the outside they can look identical (Edmunds). The Model Y usually seats five, with a seven-seat third row offered on the Long Range All-Wheel Drive (Edmunds). If you need those seats, get a photo of them in the actual car.

Plaid is Tesla’s tri-motor setup, and it isn’t the same car as a dual-motor Model S or Model X (Edmunds). Don’t pay a Plaid price just because the headline used the word Plaid.

Full Self-Driving, or FSD, is generally tied to the car when it was purchased outright. A monthly subscription does not stay with the car for the next owner (Tesla). Tesla has run limited-time promotions to transfer a purchased FSD package to a new Tesla, and its support page says that program ended on March 31, 2026 (Tesla). Confirm on the screen whether FSD is actually on the car.

Motorphilia has been Your Automotive Matchmaker since 2002, and we were certified to work on Teslas in 2022. From our home base in Tyler, TX, we help buyers all over the country and deliver nationwide. When we price a used Tesla, we don’t stop at the model year. We look at the computer, the battery, the seats, and the software that’s actually on the car.

That’s the whole point. Two Teslas from the same year can both be good cars. They’re not interchangeable, and they shouldn’t be priced as if they were.

If you want help finding the right car, start with our Match Maker. You can also call or text us anytime at (430) 247-2588. We’re here 24/7.

Check us out at www.motorphilia.com, and keep us in mind for any car needs, especially Tesla!