Here’s my take on hail damage on a used car: I don’t automatically walk away just because a storm left dings on the hood. Hail is not all the same. Some of it is a straightforward fix. Some of it is a real problem. The word “hail” in a listing does not tell you which one you’re looking at.

Why hail damage on a used car varies so much

The National Weather Service measures hail by diameter and compares it to everyday objects. Pea-size hail is a quarter inch. Quarter-size hail is one inch. Golf-ball hail is 1.75 inches, and baseball-size hail is 2.75 inches (NWS). A storm is officially severe when it can produce hail an inch or larger, or wind gusts over 58 mph. Hail that size can damage plants, roofs, and vehicles (NWS).

That’s the point. A few shallow dimples on a hood are one thing. Broken glass, cracked paint, or deep, stretched metal is another. You have to look at the car, not just the label.

When paintless dent repair can fix it

A lot of hail marks can be taken out with paintless dent repair, or PDR. That’s a method that massages the dent out from the back of the panel without grinding, filling, or repainting (NAPDRT). The factory paint stays on the car. The National Alliance of Paintless Dent Repair Technicians says hail damage is typically fixed in one day with PDR, while a conventional body shop may take two to three weeks for the same kind of damage. They also say PDR repairs are typically about one-quarter to one-third the cost of a conventional dent repair (NAPDRT).

PDR is not magic, though. The same group says the most important factors are depth and location. A dent the size of a dinner plate can be fixed if it is not too deep. A dent as small as a dime may be too deep if the metal is stretched. Cracked paint is often a sign that a dent went too far. They estimate that about 95 percent of minor dents can be repaired this way, and about 5 percent cannot because of depth or a bad location, such as a tight edge or a heavily braced part of a hood (NAPDRT).

What I look at before I decide

So I treat hail like any other damage. I look at the size of the hits. I look at whether the paint is still intact. I look at whether a good PDR tech can get behind the panel. And I look at what it will reasonably cost to make the car right. If the dents are shallow, the paint is good, and the repair is straightforward, hail does not scare me off. If the glass is broken, the paint is cracked, or the metal is stretched, that’s a different conversation.

I also want clear photos of the roof, hood, trunk, and the tops of the fenders, because that’s where hail usually lands. A listing that only shows the sides of the car is not enough. Walk around it in good light, or have someone do it for you, and look at the reflections on the panels. Hail marks show up there.

Motorphilia has been Your Automotive Matchmaker since 2002. From our home base in Tyler, TX, we help buyers all over the country and deliver nationwide. When we shop a car, we don’t stop at a single word in the description. We look at the actual damage and what it takes to fix it.

That’s the whole point. Hail damage on a used car can be a minor cosmetic issue or a costly repair. Both happen. They’re not the same. Judge the dents, not just the word hail.

If you want help finding the right car, start with our Match Maker. You can also call or text us anytime at (430) 247-2588. We’re here 24/7.

Check us out at www.motorphilia.com, and keep us in mind for any car needs, especially Tesla!