A $9,000 Tesla Model S. New battery. Free charging for life. New tires. “No issues.”
Sounds like the deal of the year, right? That’s the point. I see listings like this all the time on Facebook Marketplace, and this one is a perfect example of how “bargain cars” get sold. The real story isn’t the price. It’s what the seller never said.
It’s a red 2015 Model S 85D in Frisco, Texas, posted November 16 in a Facebook group called Teslas For Sale By Owner.
Here is the seller’s description, word for word:
Battery replaced in 2021 under warranty to new battery , unlimited free charging for life . VIN number in the picture . I will not clean the car and wear and tear will be there . That’s why priced it low to get rid of it . No issues and brand new tires put on 6 months ago . If you are picky buyer don’t worry about this.
Read it again. The low price is supposedly about wear and tear, and the fact that the seller won’t clean it. You know what word never shows up? Title.


Mileage is not in the listing either. Another member of the group asked “miles????” and did not get an answer. What did show up later was a comment from another member of the group: “Just an FYI to everyone this is a salvage vin but it was salvaged in 2019.”
That’s a buried lead. The battery, the charging, and the tires all got top billing. The single most important fact about the car got left for a stranger to post in the comments.
The VIN is on the door-jamb label in the photos: 5YJSA1H11FFP77192. The label shows a March 2015 build date. We are pulling a history report on that VIN now.


So we ran it. Here’s what came back.
The commenter was close. On March 24, 2019, an insurance company declared this car a total loss. The free NICB VINCheck shows the same thing, a salvage record with that same date of loss. And here’s the twist: the Carfax shows no salvage, rebuilt, or junk brand on the title. Not every insurance total loss ends up as a branded title, so on paper this one can look clean. That’s exactly why you can’t stop at “clean title.”
It doesn’t stop there. The report also shows minor damage a few weeks after the total loss, in April 2019, and a minor-to-moderate rear-end collision in June 2020 that hit the right rear, right side, and left rear. So much for “no issues.”
Remember the unanswered question about miles? The last recorded odometer reading was 143,794 miles in May 2024, and the car has been registered since then, so it’s likely higher today.
And the new battery? Nothing in the report shows a battery replacement in 2021 or any other year. To be fair, work done at a Tesla service center often never makes it onto a Carfax, so that claim is unproven, not disproven. But it’s the headline of the listing, and there’s nothing on paper to back it up.
Why sellers bury it
A cheap Tesla is easy to fall for, and a total loss is easy to skip if the listing stays busy talking about something else. “Priced it low to get rid of it” and a warning to picky buyers don’t explain a car an insurer wrote off.
To be fair, a car that was totaled isn’t automatically a bad car. If it’s priced like one and the history is right there in the listing, a buyer can make an informed call. The problem isn’t the total loss. It’s the hiding.
What a total loss costs you on a Tesla, even with a clean title
Normally, a totaled car ends up with a salvage brand. In Texas, a salvage vehicle is one damaged enough that the cost of repair, parts and labor included, was more than the car was worth beforehand. Insurance companies usually make that call (Texas Department of Motor Vehicles). You cannot legally drive it until it has been rebuilt and inspected, and the title still carries a rebuilt-salvage brand. It will always be worth substantially less than a comparable clean-title car, and insurance is often denied, so check with your agent before you buy (TxDMV, Texas Department of Insurance).
On a Tesla, a clean-looking title doesn’t get you off the hook. Under Tesla’s official Unsupported Vehicle Policy, a car that was declared a total loss is an unsupported vehicle even if its title was never branded, the same as a salvage, rebuilt, or junk car, and Tesla does not recommend buying one. Warranties and extended service agreements are void. Tesla does not warrant the car’s safety or operability, and will not perform or support high-voltage battery repairs until it confirms the car meets its standards. Supercharging and other fast charging stay off until the car passes a paid Fast Charging Safety Inspection. Even then, the car stays unsupported, and the warranties stay void (Tesla, TN-18-00-001 R5). A service center may still do some work, including recalls if the car is safe to repair, or it may decline the job.
And don’t take “unlimited free charging for life” on faith. I could not find official Tesla wording that this benefit automatically transfers to a private-party buyer. If Tesla classifies the car as unsupported, Supercharging can be turned off. Confirm the status in the seller’s Tesla app, and check the history first.
How to read between the lines of a bargain listing
Look for what is missing:
- Mileage is not listed, or a direct question about miles goes unanswered.
- The seller says it is priced low to get rid of it.
- The listing warns picky buyers away.
- The title is never mentioned.
- The VIN is in a photo. Use it.
You can check a VIN yourself before you message the seller. Start at vehiclehistory.gov for an official NMVTIS report with title brands, recent odometer readings, and salvage or total-loss records. Then run a free NICB VINCheck for insurance-reported salvage, flood, and theft records. VINCheck is a first look, not a complete history, so treat a clean result as no red flag found, not as proof.
How Motorphilia sorts this out
Motorphilia has helped people buy cars since 2002. We are based in Tyler, Texas, we deliver nationwide, and we were certified to work on Teslas in 2022. We check history and condition on every car, and we never take branded titles like salvage or rebuilt.
A $9,000 Model S with a new battery and new tires can look like a gift. It can also be a car you cannot insure the way you expected, cannot Supercharge the way the listing promised, and cannot sell later for anything close to what a car with a clean history brings.
This is just one more reason to use Motorphilia, to sort the trash out before the trash sorts you.
If you want help finding the right car, start with our Match Maker at https://motorphilia.com/matchmaker/. You can also call or text us anytime at (430) 247-2588. We’re here 24/7.
Check us out at www.motorphilia.com, and keep us in mind for any car needs, especially Tesla!
Sources
1. Texas Department of Motor Vehicles. “Salvage Vehicles.” A salvage motor vehicle was damaged to the extent that the cost of repair, including materials and labor, was more than the vehicle was worth before it was damaged; insurance companies usually make this determination. The vehicle cannot be operated on the road until it is rebuilt and inspected. Buyers should consider insurability and resale value and get a title history report. https://www.txdmv.gov/motorists/buying-or-selling-a-vehicle/title-check-look-before-you-buy/salvage-brands
2. Texas Department of Motor Vehicles. “Rebuilt Vehicles.” A rebuilt vehicle was branded salvage and then restored to road worthiness; a Texas title will include the “Rebuilt Salvage” brand. Rebuilt vehicles will always be worth substantially less because they were salvage vehicles. They are often denied insurance; check with an insurance agent before purchasing. https://www.txdmv.gov/motorists/buying-or-selling-a-vehicle/title-check-look-before-you-buy/rebuilt
3. Texas Department of Insurance (updated July 23, 2026). “My car was totaled! Now what?” A totaled vehicle may be issued a salvage title, and after repairs a new title is required from TxDMV before it can be driven. A vehicle that had a salvage title could be harder to sell or insure in the future. https://www.tdi.texas.gov/tips/car-totaled.html
4. Tesla, Inc., Tech Note TN-18-00-001 R5 (July 17, 2025). “Unsupported Vehicle Policy.” An unsupported vehicle includes one declared a total loss, or registered or titled as salvage, rebuilt, or junk (clean-title vehicles can still be classified as unsupported). Tesla limited warranties and extended service agreements are void. Tesla does not warrant the safety or operability of unsupported vehicles and does not recommend purchasing one. Until Tesla confirms the vehicle meets its safety standards, Tesla does not perform or support repairs involving high voltage battery systems. Fast charging, including Supercharging and third-party fast charging, remains disabled until the vehicle passes a Fast Charging Safety Inspection at the owner’s request and expense; even then, the vehicle remains unsupported and warranties remain void. Recall repairs may be performed if the vehicle is safe to repair. Service centers may decline work. The mobile app remains supported. https://service.tesla.com/docs/ServiceBulletins/External/TN/TN-18-00-001_Unsupported_Vehicle_Policy_R5.pdf
5. Tesla, Inc., New Vehicle Limited Warranty, North America (effective September 1, 2026). Tesla may void the New Vehicle Limited Warranty as to vehicles that do not have a clean title or have been sold, designated, labeled, or branded as dismantled, fire-damaged, flood-damaged, junk, rebuilt, salvage, reconstructed, irreparable, or a total loss, and vehicles that have been determined to be a total loss by an insurance company. https://digitalassets.tesla.com/tesla-contents/image/upload/tesla-new-vehicle-limited-warranty-en-us.pdf
6. U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance / NMVTIS. “For Consumers.” Before purchasing a vehicle, consumers can search NMVTIS for current title information, brand history (such as junk, salvage, or flood), the latest reported odometer reading, insurance salvage or total-loss determinations, and junk or salvage-yard transfer reports. Access starts at https://www.vehiclehistory.gov (redirects to https://vehiclehistory.bja.ojp.gov/). Consumer explainer: https://vehiclehistory.bja.ojp.gov/nmvtis_consumers
7. National Insurance Crime Bureau. “VINCheck Lookup: Free Vehicle History Check.” Free VIN lookup for insurer-reported stolen, salvage, or flood records from participating NICB member companies. Limited to five searches per IP address per 24 hours. It is not a comprehensive vehicle history report and should not be relied on alone when purchasing a vehicle. https://www.nicb.org/vincheck
Leave A Comment